If you’ve spent any time scrolling through Instagram or TikTok lately, you’ve probably noticed a big shift in how people feed their dogs. Gone are the days of mystery kibble—today’s pet parents are all about real, human-grade food made with ingredients they can actually recognize. Two brands that keep popping up in those conversations are Ollie and Maev.
At first glance, they might seem similar—both deliver fresh, high-quality meals straight to your door—but they take very different approaches. Ollie slow-cooks its meals to lock in flavor and nutrients (think homemade stew for dogs). Maev, on the other hand, focuses on raw nutrition done right—no prep, no mess, just nutrient-dense, flash-frozen raw food you scoop straight from the bag.
I decided to test them side by side with my dog Freya, who takes her taste-testing duties very seriously. Here’s how these two heavyweights stack up in terms of quality, convenience, price, and, most importantly, what your dog will actually eat.
Ollie vs Maev: Side-by-Side Comparison
*Pricing varies by dog size, calorie needs, and plan. Estimates based on average large-breed portions.
How it Works
Both Ollie and Maev are subscription-based, direct-to-door dog food services. You’ll start by answering a few quick questions about your dog’s age, size, activity level, and dietary needs.
Ollie: After completing the questionnaire, Ollie builds a personalized meal plan just for your pup. You can choose from fresh cooked meals or gently baked recipes, and even add treats or supplements. Each box includes a cute storage container, feeding scoop, and transition guide—little touches that make mealtime smoother.
Maev: Maev skips the cooking altogether and delivers ready-to-serve raw dog food made from 100% human-grade ingredients. The food arrives in a resealable, freezer-friendly bag filled with small frozen cubes that you scoop and thaw as needed—no cutting or portioning required. Each recipe is nutritionally complete and balanced by vets and animal nutritionists, so your dog gets the benefits of raw feeding without the hassle or cleanup.
Ingredient Quality & Nutrition:
Maev Wins for Innovation, Ollie for Transparency
Both brands use human-grade ingredients, with no fillers, artificial flavors, or preservatives. They’re formulated to meet AAFCO standards and deliver complete, balanced nutrition.
Ollie uses high-quality meats, fruits, and vegetables—nothing weird or unrecognizable on the label. Every recipe is slow-cooked to preserve nutrients and flavor. What really sets them apart is transparency: you can view every recipe’s full ingredient list, guaranteed analysis, and nutrition info right on their website—no questionnaire required.
Maev takes a different route by keeping everything raw and unprocessed. Their flash-frozen cubes lock in natural nutrients and enzymes that can be lost during cooking. Each recipe includes functional ingredients like wild blueberries for antioxidants, bone broth for joint support, and sweet potato for gut health. It’s about as close as you can get to feeding a natural raw diet—without the risk or the prep time.
If you’re looking for a lightly cooked, easy-to-serve option, Ollie shines. But if you’re interested in raw nutrition and higher nutrient retention, Maev’s formula is tough to beat.
Maev, along with a team of PhD Veterinary Nutritionists, formulated their protein-rich Raw Food with 11 core ingredients including lean Beef or Chicken (plus Liver, Gizzard, and Sweetbreads), fresh vegetables and fruits, and functional supplements in every serving.
GUARANTEED BEST PRICE
SAVE 30% OFF YOUR FIRST PURCHASE WITH CODE CHOW30
Taste, Texture & Variety:
Depends on Your Dog’s Preferences
Freya’s a foodie, so this one was fun to test.
Ollie’s meals have a soft, stew-like texture that mixes well with dry food or stands alone. Freya loves both the fresh and baked recipes (I even use the baked ones as training treats).
Maev’s raw cubes are bite-sized and thaw quickly, making portioning simple. Freya was curious at first but took to them surprisingly fast—especially when I mixed a few cubes in with her Ollie food. I like that Maev’s texture mimics fresh meat without being messy or greasy.
Recipe Variety:
Ollie: 4 fresh recipes (Beef, Chicken, Turkey, Lamb) + 2 baked recipes (Beef, Chicken)
Maev: 5 raw recipes (Beef, Chicken, Turkey, Venison, and Lamb)
Both brands keep their recipes limited to high-quality proteins, but Maev wins in terms of variety of proteins. They also offer more novel proteins, making them ideal for dogs with allergies.
Packaging & Convenience:
Ollie for Extras, Maev for Simplicity
Both brands ship frozen in eco-friendly boxes designed to keep meals cold for hours.
Ollie’s packaging feels more complete—you’ll get organized meal trays, feeding tools, and clear serving instructions.
Maev’s resealable bags take up less space in the freezer, which is great for smaller kitchens. The raw cubes make it easy to scoop out exactly what you need without thawing a full portion. There’s no extra packaging waste, either.
If you like structure and extra goodies, Ollie’s starter kit is hard to beat. If you prefer a minimalist approach, Maev’s system is refreshingly simple.
Price: Maev Is Slightly More Affordable
Pricing varies depending on your dog’s weight and plan type, but here’s what it looks like for my large-breed dog:
Ollie Fresh Plan: about $65–$75 per week
Ollie Half-Fresh Plan: about $40 per week
Maev Raw Plan: about $50–$60 per week
Both brands offer steep discounts on your first order, though. See below for the latest deals.
Maev, along with a team of PhD Veterinary Nutritionists, formulated their protein-rich Raw Food with 11 core ingredients including lean Beef or Chicken (plus Liver, Gizzard, and Sweetbreads), fresh vegetables and fruits, and functional supplements in every serving.
GUARANTEED BEST PRICE
SAVE 30% OFF YOUR FIRST PURCHASE WITH CODE CHOW30
Fresh, human-grade food made from real ingredients for a healthier pup today and tomorrow. Recipes made from whole food ingredients, slow cooked for nutrition and flavor and always fresh.
LIMITED TIME OFFER
80% OFF YOUR FIRST BOX +
FREE JERKY FOR LIFE & FREE LICK MAT
Ends 12/2/25
Final Verdict:
Ollie for Cooked Variety, Maev for True Raw Nutrition
Both brands are stellar choices for dog parents who want to feed real, healthy food. They’re also VASTLY different in terms of type of food. So, I can’t really declare a “winner” here since it really depends on what you’re looking for in dog food.
✅ Choose Ollie if you want:
Fresh-cooked, human-grade meals with baked options
- Fun extras and treats in your plan
A great choice for picky eaters
🥩 Choose Maev if you want:
100% raw nutrition without the prep or mess
Bite-sized cubes for easy serving and portion control
- Functional ingredients that support whole-body health
At the end of the day, Ollie makes it effortless to feed your dog wholesome, home-style meals, while Maev takes things a step further by offering the purest form of nutrition—raw, functional, and as close to nature as it gets. If you’re ready to level up your dog’s diet, Maev just might be the brand that sets a new standard.
